News

Lethal injection resumes in state

Published: Tuesday, October 23, 2007 at 3:30 a.m.
Last Modified: Monday, October 22, 2007 at 10:43 p.m.

Montgomery - Gov. Bob Riley resumed state executions Monday after a change in lethal injection procedures that halted the scheduled execution of Tommy Douglas Arthur in September.

Riley said the planned execution of terminally ill Danial Lee Siebert will proceed Thursday as scheduled. Siebert has appeals in federal court that could stay his execution.

After Siebert's planned execution is Arthur's, who was scheduled to die by lethal injection Sept. 27. On that day, Riley stayed his execution for 45 days pending a change in the state's method of lethal injection.

Opponents of Alabama's death penalty said lethal injection is cruel and unusual punishment.

They said it leaves too great a chance the condemned will suffer because there's the possibility that the lethal injection causes pain and because it could also cause paralysis and the condemned is unable to communicate that pain to those administering the injection.

The new protocol involves a series of steps designed to test an inmate's unconsciousness once a nonfatal knockout drug is given in preparation for a lethal dose of chemicals.

Department of Corrections spokesman Brian Corbett said the new protocol is a "generally accepted means for assessing consciousness."

The steps include calling the inmate by name, brushing the inmate's eyelashes, and pinching the inmate's arm. "A member from the execution team is on hand to perform those grading stimuli," Corbett said.

Siebert's execution date had been set when Arthur was granted a brief hiatus. Siebert's supporters said he shouldn't be executed because he's suffering from terminal pancreatic cancer, which Riley addressed in a statement.

Riley said Siebert was given the death sentence and any action by him would result in a life sentence. "His crimes were monstrous, brutal and ghastly," Riley said.

Siebert, 53, was convicted of the strangulation deaths of a mother and her two sons in Talladega County in 1986: Sherri Weathers, her sons, 5-year-old Chad and 4-year-old Joey, and for killing a neighbor, Linda Jarman. Weathers was a student at the Alabama School for the Blind and had been dating Siebert.

Attorneys for Siebert did not immediately return phone calls seeking comment. They have asked federal and state courts to block his execution on grounds the drugs used to kill him could interact with his medication and cause undue pain.

Arthur was convicted for the 1982 shooting death of Muscle Shoals resident Troy Wicker.

Arthur's attorney, Sunaha Han, of New York, said Alabama's new lethal injection protocol could end up being unconstitutional.

"Because the state cannot possibly have any interest in executing Mr. Arthur in an unconstitutional manner, the state should not proceed with Mr. Arthur's execution until the constitutionality of Alabama's revised protocol has been fully addressed," Han said.

Attorney General Troy King asked the Alabama Supreme Court to reset an execution date for Arthur, but the court had not set a date as of Monday, the clerk's office said.

Siebert filed a challenge to his execution in federal court in Montgomery. Arthur has challenged his execution to the U.S. Supreme Court and wants DNA testing of crime scene evidence to prove his proclaimed innocence.

"Instead of trying to rush the execution of Mr. Arthur by a method whose constitutionality is being challenged, the state should grant Mr. Arthur's request for DNA testing, which would not cost the state anything and which would not delay his execution," Han said.

Dana Beyerle can be reached at (334) 264-6605.


Comments

    Post a comment | View all comments on this topic.
  1. FirenzeVeritas says...
    October 23, 2007 2:18:08 am

    RE: http://www.timesdaily.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20.../NEWS/710230314/1011

    I cannot believe anyone would actually prefer a death from pancreatic cancer to one from painless lethal injection. If the State wished to practice cruel and unusual punishment, they should let the condemned die from his disease. I infer the attorney in this case is using it for his own political agenda.

    Report this comment

  2. Kindred says...
    October 23, 2007 3:24:01 am

    A man I work with lost his wife to pancreatic cancer, and the trauma of watching her in so much pain is STILL with this family and it has been nearly five years. It is a very painful way to go. You are right.

    Report this comment

  3. bullit says...
    October 23, 2007 3:35:06 am

    It is about time. Now lets get on with it. No more stalling or frivilous lawsuits and stall tactics.
    Now lets work on the amount of time someone sentenced to die gets to sit on death row. It needs to be shortened greatly. Put a time limit on appeals then proceed with the executions.

    Report this comment

  4. bama1chas says...
    October 23, 2007 8:46:10 am

    I agree bullit. It's ridiculous how long we let someone sit on death row. The state could save a ton of money on what we pay to feed and clothe these people after they have been sentenced, not to mention reducing the overcrowding of our prisons.

    Report this comment

  5. unclegus says...
    October 23, 2007 9:01:33 am

    I don't know Mr. Aurther, nor do I know much about his case, but it bothers me to see his face on the paper so much. He really is a sickening looking person, I will be glad when they do what has to be done, and quit putting his picture on the times daily. For what it's worth, I think every time they put it in the paper, it has to be tormenting the survivors of his victims unjustly.
    I can only hope that if I am ever in their situation, I will not be so tormented.

    Report this comment

  6. thehippiegirl is gone. says...
    October 23, 2007 10:34:32 am

    i had similar thoughts about dying from the cancer vs injection....and i think most would agree, it's way-past-time to carry out the sentence given to mr arthur..God bless the victims' families, maybe justice will bring some closure, or at least give them peace..

    Report this comment

  7. SHELDIVR says...
    October 23, 2007 3:18:52 pm

    Any time the perpetrator outlives his victims by nearly three decades, justice has already taken a pretty severe beating.

    Report this comment

  8. FirenzeVeritas says...
    October 23, 2007 11:38:55 pm

    The bulk of the money spent on keeping these individuals incarcerated is for salaries. Money spent on food and clothing is neglible compared to the wages that must be paid their correction officers. Note: I'm not saying COs are overpaid, just that food/clothing is a very small part of their upkeep.

    Report this comment

  9. FirenzeVeritas says...
    October 25, 2007 1:27:38 pm

    This execution, as of Wed., is still scheduled for Thursday at six p.m.

    Report this comment

Next Article in Police & Courts

  • Chief: El Rey not violating law

    While the owner of El Rey Restaurant might have broken a promise to police, he hasn't broken any laws by operating at times more like a nightclub than a restaurant, Police Chief Greg Ray said.
    Ray had asked the city council to suspend or revoke ...